Sponsored by Johnson & Johnson Medical Affairs
How Do Different IOL Categories Tolerate Residual Astigmatism?
The quality of current intraocular lens (IOL) technologies allows us to match a growing list of patients to lenses that achieve their desired visual outcomes. As new full visual range (FVR) lenses reach the market, there is increasing awareness of how they tolerate residual postoperative astigmatism compared to older multifocal IOLs. This analysis is essential because, despite advances in biometry and IOL formulas, 8-10% of patients may still have a significant prediction error of more than 0.5 D that affects refractive outcomes.1-3 Lenses with low tolerance for residual postoperative astigmatism may fail to produce the desired result, resulting in unhappy patients and higher enhancement rates. A greater tolerance not only allows more patients to achieve their visual goals in the immediate postoperative period, but also helps to keep their clear vision longer as astigmatic changes occur with age.
To understand the tolerance of residual postoperative astigmatism across IOL modalities, my colleagues and I led a prospective observational study comparing tolerance to induced astigmatism (TIA) in 100 patients who received four types of IOLs4: standard monofocal (TECNIS™ ZCB00) (n = 20), enhanced monofocal (TECNIS Eyhance™) (n = 20), diffractive violet light filter (VLF) extended depth of field (extended DOFi) (TECNIS Symfony™ OptiBlue™) (n = 30), and VLF FVR (TECNIS Odyssey™ IOL) (n = 30). The study yielded some surprising results that may expand the use of VLF FVR lenses.
Comparative study of four IOL categories
In the study of four types of IOLs, astigmatic defocus (0.5–2.0 D) was simulated in with-the-rule (WTR), against-the rule (ATR), and oblique orientations at postoperative months 1, 2, and 3. Visual acuity was assessed as well. The results5 showed consistent trends:
- Distance-corrected intermediate visual acuity. VLF extended DOFi produced significantly better results than all other IOLs.
- Distance-corrected near visual acuity. The VLF FVR IOL outperformed all other IOLs.
- WTR astigmatism. With WTR astigmatism ≤1.0, there was no statistically significant difference between the four IOLs. The VLF FVR had similar tolerance to all other lenses up to 2.0 D.
- Oblique astigmatism. The VLF FVR had similar tolerance to all other lenses up to 1.5 D. At 0.5 D, the enhanced monofocal fared better than the VLF extended DOFi, and it performed better than any lens at 2.0 D.
- ATR astigmatism. At all magnitudes, the enhanced monofocal IOL showed the highest tolerance.
Because enhanced monofocal IOLs have shown a high tolerance to induced astigmatism in previous research,6 it was no surprise that they showed the highest TIA, particularly for oblique and ATR astigmatism. However, results for the VLF FVR and VLF extended DOFi lenses were surprising because previous studies with other presbyopia-correcting IOLs have shown them to be less tolerant of residual astigmatism than monofocal IOLs.7-9 In our study, TIA had no statistically significant difference among all the lenses with low to moderate induced WTR astigmatism. For surgeons who have worked with previous-generation FVR and extended DOFi lenses, the expectations have changed.
More candidates, more confident surgeons
With a larger landing zone that ensures clear distance vision, even with low residual astigmatism, my colleagues and I feel more confident recommending VLF FVR IOLs to a wider pool of candidates. We have also found that PRK and LASIK enhancement rates for new VLF FVR IOLs in our practice are very low. And fewer touchups mean more satisfied patients. I look forward to seeing more comparative studies of IOL tolerance, as well as patient-reported outcomes and visual symptoms.
Ready to Claim Your Credits?
You have attempts to pass this post-test. Take your time and review carefully before submitting.
Good luck!
Recommended
- A New Era of Advanced IOLs
Quality of Vision with the TECNIS PureSee™ IOL Elevates Extended Depth-of-Focus IOLs
Eric Donnenfeld, MDEric Donnenfeld, MD - A New Era of Advanced IOLs
High Refractive Tolerance and Patient Satisfaction Make the TECNIS PureSee™ EDOF IOL a Welcome Addition to Refractive Cataract Surgery
Vance Thompson, MD, FACSVance Thompson, MD, FACS
